Karma: 393700

If a woman drinks every evening, but deosn't get drunk, does that make her an alchoholic ?

My friend, A, drinks a half pint of straight whiskey sometimes more, every evening . She doesn't get drunk, per se, but she gets to acting silly or argumentative. She claims she's not drunk. She never gets a hang over. Is she an alcoholic if she doesn't get drunk ? She had been rather drunk on occasion, but not for a long time . She works during the day time.

Answer this

+5 Views: 870 Answers: 7 Posted: 10 years ago

Tags: alchohol

7 Answers

jhharlan

Karma: 1457205

I wrote a long paragraph but what it all comes down to: an alcoholic is a person who will break not the law, not the written rules but their own rules…. Simple as that. Does your friend break her own rules?

10 years ago. Rating: 11
Comment this answer

mycatsmom

I don't know what her rules are, except maybe she says she doesn't drink during the daytime......at least on a working day . Maybe she broke that rule.
Thanks for responding, jh .

commented 10 years ago

terryfossil 1

Karma: 419245

an alcoholic is someone who depends on alcohol,,if it controls you ,then you have a problem,alcohol changes everybody,if you drink and get happy,,then stop,you are in control,,if you drink and get angry,you have lost control..

10 years ago. Rating: 10
Comment this answer

Ducky

Karma: 1032550

For seven years, I worked for an alcoholic boss. Did he admit that he was an alcoholic? No and some of his friends agreed with his assessment. Why? Because he never had a hangover, he never missed work and twice a year, he quit drinking for a month. ("See, that proves I'm not an alcoholic".) His wife put up with his moods at home, watched him fall asleep every night after supper, never do anything with his three kids, and never take her anywhere, ever...just drank!

After many years, she left saying "Those two months out of twelve, just aren't worth it anymore". Amazingly, many people didn't think he was an alcoholic because they didn't SEE his personality changes and he could quit for a period of time. He was still an alcoholic....and yes, he knew it.

10 years ago. Rating: 9
Comment this answer

Bob/PKB

Once an alcoholic (or any substance abuser), always an alcoholic (substance abuser). It is a day by day process, and, just like anything else, you can't rest on yesterday's success for today's challenges.
I'm always on pins and needles re: drugs and my sons. Always will be, and they could go the rest of their (far past my) lives without a relapse, and I'll worry on my death bed (or wherever I may be).

commented 10 years ago

Ducky

I've known many loved ones of "substance abusers", more than I would like. If the abuser quits, there is still the constant "worry, what if, and I hope". :(

commented 10 years ago

mycatsmom

Yes.That's like my friend,A. She has quit at times, but not for very long. That's sad that your boss never paid attention to his kids.

commented 10 years ago

Bob/PKB

Karma: 945575

I'm going to venture out with a definite answer, and say "YES", I think she is an alcoholic. You have your own definition of "drunk", but if her blood alcohol level were tested, I'll wager she would be in the "legally drunk" range.

Now what?

10 years ago. Rating: 8
Comment this answer

pythonlover

Karma: 797301

She's certainly a habitual drinker and the amount she is drinking could eventually harm her health. Can she go for a week without any alcohol and not miss it?