close
    Thanksgiving traditions?

    It's coming....another Thanksgiving in the USA (4th Thursday in November).  Many other countries and nations celebrate Thanksgiving at other times, so we all have that in common.  


    Do you have any family traditions that go with the holiday?  Can't be without recipes? What makes YOUR celebration special? 


    One thing I wonder about is how schools are teaching about Thanksgiving's historical beginning...which I was taught was a celebration to give thanks to God for a bountiful harvest and surviving the first year at Plymouth.  Do we just conveniently eliminate the faith part? Should we even call it "Thanksgiving"?  

    +6  Views: 4271 Answers: 5 Posted: 10 years ago

    5 Answers

    It's not celebrated over here.I think the general attitude is we built this country ourselves with hard work,blood,sweat & tears.So who we gunna thank?

    Bob/PKB

    Well, golly, don't hurt your arms patting yourselves on the back!
    I will thank you for your honest answer! :D
    mycatsmom

    Tommy, you can be just plain grateful that you have food and your house without even having someone to thank for it. Our country too, was built by HARD work, by the railroad men, the miners, lumbering industry, .......and on and on.
    Tommyh

    I don't have to be grateful to anyone for the food on my table.My hard work puts it there.

    Not celebrated here, although in the ROMOS household the Fleamily will be eating well on the last Thursday in November, don't know why but I think turkey may be on the menu.

    Bob/PKB

    It wouldn't surprise me, either!
    mycatsmom

    You can take the girl out of the country, but you cannot take the country out of the girl :-)

    I was raised believing that Thanksgiving was brought about by the Pilgrims. It has never been a religious entity to me. But I was always grateful for what it brought to us by way of good food and family. Even more so now that all (7+) of use have whittled down to 3 only……… Happy Thanksgiving to you, Bob. May the family come together………...

    Bob/PKB

    Thanksgiving, or Thanksgiving Day, is a holiday celebrated in the United States on the fourth Thursday in November. It became an official Federal holiday in 1863, when, during the Civil War, President Abraham Lincoln proclaimed a national day of "Thanksgiving and Praise to our beneficent Father who dwelleth in the Heavens", to be celebrated on the last Thursday in November.[1] Also, there are reports that the original Thanksgiving proclamation was signed by George Washington.[2] As a federal and public holiday in the U.S., Thanksgiving is one of the major holidays of the year. Together with Christmas and New Year, Thanksgiving is a part of the broader holiday season.

    The event that Americans commonly call the "First Thanksgiving" was celebrated by the Pilgrims after their first harvest in the New World in 1621.[3] This feast lasted three days, and it was attended by 90 Native Americans (as accounted by attendee Edward Winslow)[4] and 53 Pilgrims.[5] The New England colonists were accustomed to regularly celebrating "thanksgivings"—days of prayer thanking God for blessings such as military victory or the end of a drought.[6]
    WIKIPEDIA
    Bob/PKB

    And to you, Julie! Many blessings to you and yours!
    jhharlan

    So, I wasn’t wrong in my beliefs and why. Fact state that the pilgrims massacred the Indian at the feast. Appears that a lot of customs came from that event…...
    Bob/PKB

    Please supply a reliable reference for the massacre at the first Thanksgiving at Plymouth Rock. I am reading accounts of 20 years later that verify your comment, but nothing about 1620-1621. Thank you.
    jhharlan

    There are more articles but I figure 3 is enough. They are all on google……...
    Bob/PKB

    I looked at the first article. It references 1637. Please check again.
    jhharlan

    Was Thanksgiving really a massacre of 700 “Indians”? The present Thanksgiving may be a mixture of the 1621 three-day feast and the “Thanksgiving” proclaimed after the 1637 Pequot massacre. So next time you see the annual “Pilgrim and Indian display” in a shopping window or history about other massacres of Native Americans, think of the hurt and disrespect Native Americans feel. Thanksgiving is observed as a day of sorrow rather than a celebration. This year at Thanksgiving dinner, ponder why you are giving thanks.
    jhharlan

    What’s a few years? The point being that Thanksgiving was started by celebrating the massacre of Indians. Kind of takes away from the whole idea. Read the other articles.
    Bob/PKB

    Why on earth would it be called "thanks-giving" if someone were not being thankful for something and acknowledging it to someone? I'm getting confused with the logic here.
    jhharlan

    Read the article, seems they were thankful the massacred 700+ bad indians got out of the way……….
    Bob/PKB

    1621 My reference point is 1621
    jhharlan

    And the massacre still happened on what “they” called Thanksgiving Day. That’s the ref I remember. 16 years later. 9/11 happened when?
    I never celebrated Thanksgiving from a religious point of view. It just meant “family” to me. I will not be celebrating this year but only because there is no point anymore….

    My mums parents came from Plymouth,it was bomb quite bady during the 2world war.Its quite odd that we named so maney places in Britsh ile's afte the U,S,of A


     

    ROMOS

    Yep, just like California, a small village in the west of Scotland.
    hector5559

    another one we copy after them Ted,
    Bob/PKB

    Isn't the USA Plymouth named after YOUR Plymouth?
    ROMOS

    Indeed it is P, I'm just messing with you, and I hope Dougal is too.
    ;)
    ROMOS

    There is a California in Scotland though, also a Hollywood.
    Bob/PKB

    Which came first??? America's or Scotland's?
    ROMOS

    Hollywood has been here since the early 1500s, California was named after the gold rush in "your" California, the "gold" here was the (Black Diamond) coal, 1840.
    Bob/PKB

    History was never my favorite subject in school as a youthful person. NOW, it fascinates me. I'm going to see if FCC offers a course in GB history.
    ROMOS

    Funny you should say that, I did a degree in American economic history & American history in the early 90s to get my brain back on track after my aneurism.Also read everything I could get my hands on about the US civil war, you'll enjoy British history if you get a good tutor.
    mycatsmom

    Hect, Here, we have a lot of cities and street names that you have in Merry ole England.

    Well it's cool that it's on a thursday this year..!



    Top contributors in Holidays category

     
    jhharlan
    Answers: 17 / Questions: 0
    Karma: 1560
     
    Bob/PKB
    Answers: 7 / Questions: 11
    Karma: 1530
     
    daren1
    Answers: 12 / Questions: 1
    Karma: 1290
     
    Tommyh
    Answers: 9 / Questions: 0
    Karma: 1230
    > Top contributors chart

    Unanswered Questions

    c54centralbarnyc
    Answers: 0 Views: 1 Rating: 0
    Ytmp3 Cheap
    Answers: 0 Views: 2 Rating: 0
    Ytmp3 Cheap
    Answers: 0 Views: 2 Rating: 0
    Ytmp3 Cheap
    Answers: 0 Views: 2 Rating: 0
    Ytmp3 Cheap
    Answers: 0 Views: 2 Rating: 0
    Ytmp3 Cheap
    Answers: 0 Views: 2 Rating: 0
    Ytmp3 Cheap
    Answers: 0 Views: 2 Rating: 0
    Ytmp3 Cheap
    Answers: 0 Views: 2 Rating: 0
    > More questions...
    466429
    questions
    722239
    answers
    785341
    users