close
    Would you as a woman stick a round in a relationship, where by your so called BF is still married and only separated and not divorced, would you as a man do the same if the reverse were true? Why?, Why not? We are in our 40's, does age matter? I have no childeren of my own, while he in this case has one child from that previous relationship.

    0  Views: 1264 Answers: 7 Posted: 12 years ago
    Colleen

    Moderator
    Please continue to use the "comment this answer" link to reply to the members like you had been doing right along. Do not use the "add new answer" box as those comments will be removed. Thank you.

    7 Answers

    Well, if he has involved himself in a relationship with you for any considerable amount of time, he should know here he stands with you and be ready to make his position clear to all concerned. Otherwise, it sounds more like he is just using you as some sort of optional playmate in light of the fact he is separated. Let's face the facts here, HE'S STILL MARRIED. Separations are more a transitional period, where the concerned parties to it, have declared they are not legally responsible for their spouse's latest bills and have not fully decided upon a divorce yet.


    Those are the clear and simple facts of the matter, and that is where you stand until he makes the choice of divorcing her or not!


     

    mrsminiver

    Bravo! Couldn't have said it any bettere myself. It's not fun sitting on the fence, or sitting in the bleacher's as the game is played out. Not knowing whether your coming or going. My patience are running out.

    I would stick around if


    1.I knew for sure he wasn't still in love with his wife


    2.I was happy how he treated me


    3.I felt we had a future together

    mrsminiver

    In what way you you concider a "future" together?
    pythonlover

    Moderator
    Building a good relationship is like building a tall building: you need a strong base. In the years to come, growing together as a couple, achieving common goals and supporting one another will bring you even closer and establish a connection that is past the initial "in love" stage. Good communication and respect are the key. Also understanding that you may hit a bump every once in a while and be willing to work on it.

    Make a list of the pros and cons.  Only you can decide if this is the relationship for you or not. Two people usually stay together, only as long as both parties are still satisfied.  It has a lot to do with mutual respect, love, common interests, and what you want for your future together.

    mrsminiver

    What do you mean by "Future" together?
    Ducky

    Moderator
    I assume that your own expression "stick around" has something to do with the "future", does it not? Was that not the whole point of your question mrsminiver?

    I did comment to your answer MrsM and I would just like to add... as a woman in your 40s... Shake your head, figure out what YOU want from this life time of YOURS and make that happen.  He is just a man.  There are a lot of them out there.


    Devout Catholic my butt.  Ridiculous.  He is using his religion (which he is abusing) as an excuse.  Totally pathetic to my way of thinking.  You need a real man.

    pioneer2

    Thats saying it LIKE IT IS fishlet. TWO thumbs up to you. He's as phony as hell.

    How long have you "stuck around" so far?


    Sounds as if you're a bit fed up.


    He may just want to have his cake and eat it, too.


    Why won't he make a real commitment to you?


    Things to ponder.

    It sounds as though you have pretty much figured him and the relationship out yourself, he, an adulterous walking contradiction, and you involved with a man you obviously care about, I doubt his family will ever accept the situation, so it really comes down to what you are happy and comfortable with and if you can get past the fact that he will probably never divorce his estranged wife.All the best with whatever you choose to do, and welcome to akaQA

    mrsminiver

    Yes, I do care, I am not a complete heel. When I know once and forall whether or not he's getting a divorce or not, that will be the ultimate deciding factor as to stay in this relationship or not. There's lot's of guys out there, and it's not like he's erreplaceable.

    Very good questions, first off we've been together for a couple of yrs. Yes I agree I think he does want his cake and eat it too, as for lack of commitment to me, he's a die hard catholic, and believes strongly in the instution of marriage, till death does one part, and it would be very upsetting to her side of the family should they forgo a divorse.


    Yet, interestingly enough I have been labeled a "Gold Digger" by 'his' side of the family including the childern. I don't stand to gain five cents from being in this so called relationship, as it is limited, what with him being married.

    Ducky

    Moderator
    Please use "comment this answer" to continue conversation with a responder. Thanks.
    Dardaigh

    Well, Mrs. Miniver, I think you probably know deep in your heart what the answer is but it may take some time to face it.

    Remember, life is too short sometimes for the waiting game. He has the deck stacked in his favour.

    Just give everything some serious thought and good luck with whatever decision you make.
    mrsminiver

    Thank you 'Ducky' I am really new at this site.
    Flip

    So .... let me understand this. He is a "die hard" catholic who strongly believes in the institution of marriage, but doesn't have a problem with separating and getting a girl friend with no commitments? I seem to have a problem with that philosophy.
    mrsminiver

    Dardaigh:, I agree 100% the cards stacked in his favor, so I do not understand his family's possition towards me, in thinking that I am in some way a 'Gold Digger.'
    Flip:Your not the only one with a problem to this philosophy. At the end of the day, I'll be the one left holding the bag, as it were.
    mrsminiver

    Dardaigh:, I agree 100% the cards stacked in his favor, so I do not understand his family's possition towards me, in thinking that I am in some way a 'Gold Digger.'
    Flip:Your not the only one with a problem to this philosophy. At the end of the day, I'll be the one left holding the bag, as it were.
    Please bare with me as I try to figure out this site, I am a newbe.
    mrsminiver

    Dardaigh:, I agree 100% the cards stacked in his favor, so I do not understand his family's possition towards me, in thinking that I am in some way a 'Gold Digger.'
    Flip:Your not the only one with a problem to this philosophy. At the end of the day, I'll be the one left holding the bag, as it were.
    Please bare with me as I try to figure out this site, I am a newbe
    Dardaigh

    Mrs. Miniver, don't worry about his family labelling you, it's the least of your worries.
    They're sending a clear message that they don't want to accept you.

    I have no idea how old/young you are but this brings to mind Katherine Hepburn/Spencer Tracy.

    She was a legend in Hollywood, yet she chose to be second best to his wife because he refused to divorce her, being Catholic.
    Shootah

    He's a die hard Catholic is his reasoning for not divorcing? What is his reasoning for allowing himself to commit adultery within the marriage he religiously fears terminating? Are you kidding me?!!!!
    Dardaigh

    Very true, Shootah.

    The guy wants it both ways.
    mrsminiver

    Very true Shootah, I couldn't agree with you more, nope I am not kidding you. He doesn't apprciate it when I mention it to him either that he's committed adultery.

    Yes, Dardaigh, I think he does want it all. I think he just wants someone around for company, no stings attached, in some repects, because as I say he is married. Thing is if he were to pass on tomorrow, his wife and childern would be in like flinn, and rushing me out the door faster then one could shake their heads.

    Colleen

    Moderator
    <reply moved to where it belongs>


    _________________________________________________


    mrsminiver
    Karma: 15

    Very true Shootah, I couldn't agree with you more, nope I am not kidding you. He doesn't apprciate it when I mention it to him either that he's committed adultery.

    Yes, Dardaigh, I think he does want it all. I think he just wants someone around for company, no stings attached, in some repects, because as I say he is married. Thing is if he were to pass on tomorrow, his wife and childern would be in like flinn, and rushing me out the door faster then one could shake their heads.
    Colleen

    Moderator
    <reply moved to where it belongs>


    _________________________________________________

    mrsminiver
    Karma: 15

    Dardaigh:, I agree 100% the cards stacked in his favour, so I do not understand his family's possition towards me, in thinking that I am in some way a 'Gold Digger.'
    Flip:Your not the only one with a problem to this philosophy. At the end of the day, I'll be the one left holding the bag, as it were.
    Please bare with me as I try to figure out this site, I am a newbe.

    I am not sure where I am supossed to be replying to questions to those possing more questions, my appologies to all.

    _______________________________________________


    ROMOS Try the "comment this answer" as I just did.
    Welcome to akaQA by the way.
    Dardaigh

    Mrs. Miniver, see where you replied "Very good questions"?

    Well, it says "Comment this answer" directly below that, so even though the discussion is getting quite long, you still scroll up to your "Very good questions" and reply there.

    It is a tiny bit confusing at first but we were all newbies here once.
    Ducky

    Moderator
    Even I'm getting confused!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    (I really need (!!!!) these. lol
    Dardaigh

    Too funny, Ducky.x :)
    FISH-O

    Easy enough to figure out. If you are not Catholic and he is what you would deem as "devout"... which incidentally he is not... AND, he is just clip clip clapping along doing what ever he pleases on his own terms well then... guess what Sunshine! You don't need a Rocket Scientist to figure this one out.
    BOOM! Reality! Hard pill to swallow.
    Even if you were to change your faith... Big fat Nada for you.


    Top contributors in Uncategorized category

     
    ROMOS
    Answers: 18061 / Questions: 154
    Karma: 1101K
     
    Colleen
    Answers: 47269 / Questions: 115
    Karma: 953K
     
    country bumpkin
    Answers: 11322 / Questions: 160
    Karma: 838K
     
    Benthere
    Answers: 2392 / Questions: 30
    Karma: 760K
    > Top contributors chart
    466550
    questions
    722257
    answers
    785518
    users