close
    Should doctors strike?

    In the UK some doctors are on strike concerning changes to their pension arrangements. They have to contribute more and retire later as do many other people. Their final pension will be about    £ 60,000 pa index linked. To me this seems very generous as my wife and I live comfortably on about half this amount.


    Opinions please.

    +4  Views: 1070 Answers: 7 Posted: 12 years ago

    7 Answers

    Many professions, as you said, are paying more into their retirement funds and working to a more senior age.  Why these doctors should think they should be immune from "the times" baffles me, but I sure wouldn't want a doctor in charge of my well-being if (s)he was P.O. about being there. 
    As far as their right to strike, I would support that. It sounds like it was done in a very organized and respectful way; too bad it was construed as a "non-event". The issue was brought to light, and the doctors did not compromise their patients' well-being in doing so. If anything, I would be likely to be more supportive of their strike because they maintained their integrity. 

    A lot probably depends upon what part of the world we are talking about. But, if that is what they need to do, I hope someone is listening and remedies the situation quickly for the sake of those who need them. For doctors to even mention this option, they must be feeling very aggreived.

    nomdeplume

    These are doctors working in the British National Health Service. Does anyone earning £100k ( $160K ) and who is in line to receive a pension of £60K have any problem?
    Shootah

    It makes me wonder who paid for their edcation, as in the U.S. I know it can easily range from $500,000 to $1,000,000. That is probably a modest estimate at that, and this is not considering the interests on loans.

    But, on the other hand, if a person's first interest is in making money, perhaps they should have considered another field to work in. Without fully understanding the cost of living there, it is really hard to get a feel for it.

    Take to many bricks out of the wall and what happens? Today it is the doctors and tomorrow it will be who?

    No they should not, If they had paid all the money into their pension themselves, then thay are entitled to what ever their pensions are worth, but most of the money is paid in by the tax payer, as with all public service workers. I have been selfemployed all my life,and now my wife and I have to live on £14,000 per year between us.

    Yes I believe (Here In the UK),,,they have every right to strike!!...They end their training with debts often in excess of £30k...the juniours work on call regularly for 36 hours plus....The Government is using the GUILT card....The strikes here have been well managed imo...eg routine clinic appts put on hold,,,Dr`s are available to treat emergencies..not leaving people to die!..In fact i passed by my GP`S surgery yesterday and saw the receptionists and nurses were there..(I put in for a repeat script)..I asked the receptionists how the day was going and they said extra busy answering phone enquiries..but hospitals,E.R`s and other emergencies were all being dealt with as normal...OF COURSE!!!:-)

    Colleen

    Moderator
    No. No emergency personal has a right to strike. They should accept that when they take on the position.
    sunnyB

    Millie The strike in the UK yesterday was not about their pay,it was about their pensions, which even after the cut backs are still worth £50,000 per year. Yes most of them do a great job ,but that's alot of pension.

    First, do no harm (Hypo critic Oath)

    Do it in the states and burn your shingle.



    Top contributors in Other - Politics & Government category

     
    Benthere
    Answers: 10 / Questions: 0
    Karma: 4965
     
    Colleen
    Answers: 93 / Questions: 7
    Karma: 4285
     
    ROMOS
    Answers: 63 / Questions: 0
    Karma: 4095
     
    Ann
    Answers: 35 / Questions: 1
    Karma: 3585
    > Top contributors chart
    466434
    questions
    722240
    answers
    785352
    users