13 Answers
I think everybody did pretty good on this test. I still hear "irregardless" from adults.
I didn't know that cross wasn't the correct word. "crucifix" sounds so ... so overly holy or something.
Next time warn us that you know the correct answer. Should it read "Regardless of the reason, one who wears a cross ... (or crucifix) Why do you capitalize cross? You sure got us going on this one, Jack. : )
12 years ago. Rating: 8 | |
A crucifix (from Latin cruci fixus meaning "(one) fixed to a cross") is an independent image of Jesus on the cross with a representation of Jesus' body.
Maybe a cross means the ones without the image of the body attached to it. If so, cross would be more correct : )
Why would wearing a cross be considered a sacrilege?
12 years ago. Rating: 4 | |
For crying out loud. Good grief. So a dog pendant means someone is idolizing a dog. This is more than recockulous. I will never understand the world I live in. Oh wait, is that the beat of a different drummer? I'm outta here.
The word "idol" is pretty vague. It's often interpreted as an object worshiped as a deity in its own right, especially in the polytheistic religions, and that clearly doesn't apply in this case.
It can also be an image of the God. This is the part that's forbidden in the Ten Commandments, on the grounds that God is incorruptible and any idol represents a corruptible thing. Nobody believes that the cross stands in for God or attempts to represent Him.
What we have here is a holy symbol (or, the case of things like the Pope's ring, an actual relic). The symbol is certainly respected, and in the case of Catholics even kissed. (The Jews also kiss their Torah on occasion, and stand in its presence. I've never heard them accused of idolatry over it.)
Does that cross the line into "worship"? Some people think so. The Catholics are also accused of polytheism due to their reverence of Mary and the saints. But it's hard to disentangle that from the general antipathy of some Protestant sects towards Catholics, which stem from age-old political rivalries, when the Catholic Church was an important temporal power as well.
The Catholic word on this is the Concilio Tridentino, which says, "in images there is no divinity or virtue on account of which they are to be worshiped, that no petitions can be addressed to them, and that no trust is to be placed in them". In other words, since they know that prayers addressed to the relics won't be answered, they're not really worshiping them. They're just respecting and venerating them.
You always get this sort of thing when you try to interpret ancient texts: crucial and subtle differences in semantics are lost.
Sources: http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/07636a.htm
The words Irrgardless, jewelery and sacreligious are incorrect words, in common usage.
The correct statement would be; "Regardless the reason, one who wears a Cross as jewelry is performing a sacrilege" (The injurious treatment of a sacred object.)
Jewelery is the British pronunciation of the American word jewelry. ;)
12 years ago. Rating: 4 | |
Regardless of the reason......and cross should be crucifix.